Who chooses librarianship – the results

It’s been interesting to see the discussion that a simple theory started on twitter. On Wednesday morning I posted this survey:

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/DZK6V78

24 hours later I had over 100 replies. I realise this is a small sample and doesn’t prove anything.

My theory: People who grew up as single children (or with a 5+ year gap to the nearest sibling) and/or were ‘sickly’ and/or ‘overly-pampered’ children (any or all of these) are more likely to choose librarianship as a subject at university.

The results (quick overview):

80 out of 100 studied librarianship at postgraduate level.

  • 57 of these didn’t tick any other boxes.
  • 8 had siblings that were at least 5 years older or younger (10%).
  • 7 of them were only children (8.75%).
  • 2 of them were ‘sickly’ children (2.5%).
  • 2 of them were ‘sickly’, pampered only children (2.5%).
  • 1 of them was a ‘sickly’ only child (1.25%).
  • 1 of them was a ‘sickly’, pampered child (1.25%).
  • 1 of them was a pampered child with siblings that were at least 5 years older or younger (1.25%).

14 out of 100 studied librarianship at undergraduate level.

  • 10 of these didn’t tick any other boxes.
  • 2 of them were only children (14%).
  • 1 of them was a ‘sickly’ child.
  • 1 of them was a ‘sickly’, pampered child with siblings that were at least 5 years older or younger.

For the people who have only ticked that they studied librarianship (undergrad or postgrad) I must assume that they don’t fall into any of the categories of ‘sickly’, only or big-gap-from-nearest-sibling child, or pampered child.

Others have ticked that they were only children, ‘sickly’ children or pampered but didn’t indicate if they studied librarianship, so I will disregard these replies.

It was interesting to see that other topics were suggested during the discussion(s), for example:

  • Are there more LGBT-ers in librarianship than in other professions?
  • Looking at common character traits of librarians.
  • When did people study librarianship? First career or as a career change? Can also look at reasons and motivations.
  • Do most people work in a library before starting their librarianship studies?
  • Do people in the UK actually *choose* librarianship, or do most just study for a LIS Masters degree because they have to? (And is it worth it? And is it needed?)
  • Are middle children more likely to become librarians? What about being career-hungry?
  • Are youngest siblings most likely to become librarians?
  • Why were we attracted to the profession?
  • How self-aware are librarians?
  • Who is brave enough to admit to being overly pampered?

(If you are a LIS student you are welcome to any of these!)

My next little research topic might have to look at the same question but mainly for undergrads. That was a useful possible amendment that was pointed out.

About these ads

About Carolin Schneider

Gas station attendant of the mind (librarian), learner, reader, googler, traveller, web 2.0er, library camper. My personal views.
This entry was posted in professional involvement and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Who chooses librarianship – the results

  1. Your survey did not allow for those in the profession who did not study librarianship or a closely-related subject. One can, or at least could, get into the profession by learning on the job.

    • Carolin says:

      Yes, but that is a different research angle that would have muddied my theory.
      Of course I am aware that there are many others in the profession who have not studied librarianship and are exceptional librarians. A different discussion altogether! :)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s